24 October 2002

 



ETB outlines plans to introduce Chartered Technologist qualification

An article by Andy Morris from tce magazine, www.tcetoday.com.

ETB has begun to outline its early goals and initiatives, with the intention of generating discussion and feedback within the professional institutions.

Chief executive Alan Clark told tce of the new body’s initiatives to improve the profession’s marketing mass via interaction between government, business and industry, the science community, academia, and the institutions and trade associations.

“We have selected one objective, and one only,” said Clark: “to ensure that the supply of SET skills better matches and stimulates market need.

“SET skills don’t simply respond to market needs; they actually create them, they stimulate them. A good, well-educated SET community out there will create new innovation and new wealth. We expect to create partnerships for change to ensure that this occurs, better matching market needs and stimulating new ones.”

The Board has identified four major operating programmes to effect these partnerships and changes. Firstly, it will look to enhance education and professional development. Secondly, it will attempt to engage business and industry. Thirdly, it will develop an integrated programme to enhance public perception, and finally the organisational structure, capabilities and processes will be put in place to enable ETB’s work.

ETB’s most striking initiative is its proposal to introduce a Chartered Technologist qualification to widen the community and engage business and industry. The Hawley Report, upon which the formation of ETB is based, identified 1.4m engineers in the UK which have no affiliation to the institutions. The introduction of the Chartered Technologist aims to bring these engineers into the fold.

In addition to being an attractive, contemporary title, complementary to the Chartered Engineer and the proposed Chartered Scientist titles, and one which addresses a wider, more multi-disciplinary community, Clark sees the proposed qualification as vital to the goal of engaging business and industry with the profession.

“We see the Chartered Technologist as a multi-disciplinary professional who would have significant knowledge and experience of SET, underpinned by an academic framework. Under the heading of Technologist, we could licence companies to provide the chartered registration to their own employees. That would be a dramatic benefit to the companies, the employees, and to the profession.

“It will become part of how people progress through their own company, and it allows the companies to use the chartering process as recognition of what their employees have achieved. It is very much a status underpinned by achievement.”

The Hawley Report identified that only 600,000 of the 2m engineers in the UK are affiliated with a professional institution. ETB claims that their influence in government, industry and academia could grow if they became more coherent and cohesive, and this is what it will set out to do.

“The problem is not new,” said Clark, “but we need a new approach. The Hawley Group identified some 1500 other initiatives out there somehow involved in the same field as us. The majority of these, whilst being worthwhile and sharing good intentions, are small scale, and many of them provide valuable but very limited impact. There’s virtually no effective co-ordination across many of these initiatives, and we think that this is really where the issue lies. What we’re trying to do is to bring coherence and cohesion to that community.

“The introduction of the Chartered Technologist has been described as probably the biggest change to the structure of the profession in the last hundred years,” said Clark. “Bioengineers, nanotechnologists, people in the NHS such as radiologists – all of these people should be part of our community. The Chartered Technologist qualification will bring them on the inside, bring them into the community, therefore benefiting the entire profession.”

However, according to Trevor Evans, chief executive officer of the Institution of Chemical Engineers, ETB's proposals raise more questions than they answer.

“Alan Clark makes an interesting proposal,” comments Evans. “For Institutions and registrants, the bottom line question is where an industrially defined and awarded qualification (CTech) might sit relative to CEng and the CSci proposals currently being worked up by the Science Council.

“There are many other issues to be addressed. For example: is there a niche for any CTech qualification relative to existing titles? Here lies a huge potential for a confusion of terms. How would quality assurance issues inherent in an industry-based scheme be addressed - if it was to be employer awarded would it be transferable? Would there be CPD, ethical and conduct requirements and to whom would an errant registrant be answerable? Would Institutions be expected to provide learned society activities for this community? What standing would an employer based qualification have either nationally or internationally, relative to other UK qualifications?

“A Working Party has already been set up jointly between Engineering Council (UK) - which has Charter responsibility for qualifications matters for the engineering community - ETB and the Science Council. The answers to these and other questions are, in addition, all important inputs to the next stage of the current EC(UK) discussions on the revision of the present framework for registration (SARTOR).”
ETB has begun discussions with the institutions in order to work on the fine details of the Chartered Technologist process. “Institutions certainly could see the attraction of having an expanded membership of CTech people for whom there is a reduced burden of assessment falling on the Institutions,” Evans commented.

“However,” he added, “it is also important that CTech should not become seen as an easy alternative for people who would otherwise go for CEng. Indeed, if CTech was awarded with less rigour than CEng, its very existence would implicitly devalue the status of CEng and the equivalence which the engineering profession seeks with the other major Chartered professions, such as the accountants, architects and surveyors.”
Clark emphasised that the purpose of the ETB announcements was to air them to the existing community in order to generate feedback. “We see the institutions as a mechanism to get people involved,” he said. “Some of the things we’ll do in the future will be seen as controversial; we therefore expect and encourage the criticism, input and feedback of the institutions’ memberships.”

More reading

Partnerships key to ETB three-year plan by Steve Hill, taken from Materials World.



We will feed all of your comments through to our working group and will respond accordingly from this website.


The introduction of yet another engineering title is just adding another layer of confusion. If we have 1.4m unregistered professionals it is because they either don't know how, cannot be bothered, or see no value in being registered. Putting another title as a stop-gap between nothing and a CEng seems to add no value. You should be concentrating on education/training for these people to allow CEng registration, not just inventing a title to suit their current ability. Please don't dilute the professional qualifications any further.
Richard Blackburn

I think this would be a wonderful idea, I am currently in my final year and to be considered a Chartered Technologist would be great. These days, when we as teachers are required to develop our skills way beyound the classroom, this would enable more than professional development.
David McGill

I have been a registered "Incorporated Engineer" for many years and am proud to be called and work as an engineer. Having worked overseas for 17 years alongside engineers of all nationalities, I know the education I received in the UK via the old HNC route is more than comparable with degree qualified engineers from other countries.

Rather than introduce a "Chartered Technologist" qualification more emphasis should be placed on increasing the status of "Incorporated Engineers" and it should be made easier for those IE's with a proven track record to obtain Chartered status. Nothing will be gained by introducing a "Chartered Technologist" qualification and what happend to the "City & Guilds Full Tech Certificate?"
G.C.Tucker, IEng, MIED

Is yet another chartered title going to confuse the issue? I think so - I can't see where "Engineer" stops and "Technologist" begins. I know "Engineer" is an unpopular title in some disciplines and perhaps the new title will reach those areas. I'm told I'm more a Technologist than an Engineer (computing background) but I see myself as an Engineer: I apply basic scientific principles and engineering practice to solve practical problems.

It is the proposed implementation that really worries me. Alan Clark is quoted, "Under the heading of Technologist, we could licence companies to provide the chartered registration to their own employees." This would mean that (unlike Chartered Engineer) the title would be administered by those who would have business benefit in having staff who make the "standard". If that is not an incentive to degrade the standard, it must misunderstand marketing. Also what would happen when the Chartered Technologist leaves that company, is he no longer able to carry a title he is credited as earning. If we do this with Chartered Technologist, we risk devaluing CEng and IEng also.

If Chartered Technologist is only available through the bigger companies (and I suspect only they will afford to run this scheme) what happens to the SMEs and independent consultants? At least CEng is a level playing field - I was awarded it for my efforts and achievements not because of who I was employed by. Also, if my current employer makes me CTech and I leave, do I loose that accolade?

I'm not sure about the figure of 1.4 million engineers without institutional backing. If this really is the case, why? Are they not affiliated because they can't make the accademic standard (perhaps they have a degree in their subject that isn't recognised by the institutions but is acceptable to their employers)? Are they simply doing a job without the appropriate formation/apprentiship (and that raises other issues about what is a skill shortage)? Or is is because we allow dustmen/refuse collectors to be called "street cleaning engineers"? If there are 1.4 million unaffiliated out there, how many are in these categories and how many are real engineers? If there are real engineers, why don't they have an affiliation - surely we need to answer that question and work out the solution before we blindly offer an answer - where is the gap analysis that proves the Hawley report's conclusion?
Carol Long

As I am registered as an IEng,and recognised as an Engineer in the UK, and the rest of Europe, would the new Chartered Technologist title replace the IEng title. In many countries the IEng equivalent is called Technologist and they are treated as 2nd class, as they are not considered as engineers and cannot take responsibilty for their work. Please do not let this happen in the UK, especially as under the SARTOR 3 changes, an IEng must now be educated to, or be equivalent to a 3 year univ. degree. This to my knowledge is a higher standard than that which is in existence in most if not all of the Sydney Accord countries.
Daniel Denis Scott

The first thing to sort out would be the CEng / IEng debate before another title is brought in! There seems to be the old problem that the IEng is not seen as equal to the CEng (although IEngineers are assured that it is equal). It would appear that the CTech will replace the IEng registration. The way forward would be to have one grade of engineer, with a new title or upgrade all IEng to CEng (this solves the problem of CEng with HNC and IEng with degrees). The IEng registered members should be given the choice of taking up either the CEng or CTech registration. The major question still remains of how to assess the level, this company based registration is a major cause of concern unless it is well "policed" and the quality is assured - but it would still be open to abuse and again devaluing the level.

In my own case I am a well trained multi-disciplined engineer with a HND qualification and an Institute Management Diploma, and I have just completed a MSc in Process Manufacturing and Management and commenced an MBA. I find that I cannot gain CEng registration (I have tried unsuccessfully via the Mature Candidate route) and that my IEng registration is of little value. I would seriously consider the CTech registration If it was valued as high as CEng or my other course of action would be to cancel my membership of the engineering Institutes and possibly look at the new Chartered Manager designation (if I get my MBA).
Tim Guy

I think if people with 3 year degrees are getting put into this area, then so should all the CEngs with HNC & HND qualifications, as people with 3 year degrees are more qualified than them, but have to settle for a lower title.
Donald Grade

C.Eng, I.Eng, C.Whatever, its all a complete waste of time unless the title is protected and is pre not post nominal, i.e. Ing Smith or Eng Smith. The big differnce between the UK (& ex colonies) and the continent is the concept of completing education and BEING a "Technician" or an "Engineer" and having the sole right to use that title.

More importantly why are there 1.4 million (?) "engineers" remaining unregistered? Perhaps they do not see any value of having an unprotected title. Perhaps the ETB should conduct a grand survey to find out what this wider community want?
Chris Dagnan

Incorporated Engineers are conspicuous by their absence from Alan Clark's article. I became an IEng because I was proud to be an engineer. Is the plan to turn us into "technologists", a word I had never heard before the present debate. More detailed information about the CTech proposals is urgently needed.
John Mann

Being an I.Eng, Eng = Engineer and NOT a Technologist ... [I wonder] what is a Technologist? Is this a place you can store I.Eng people because the I.Eng title was a mistake?
Tom Cuthbert

All HNC & HND people with C.ENG status should be graded as I.Eng once they have met the requirements of SARTOR. Or Upgrade all the I.Eng to C.Eng, there is so much division here. This is the only way to fix this mess.

I think I.Eng people will become Technologists at the end of the day as I think this is the big plan. But I think it would be a financial mistake for Eng C and the appropriate institutions, as I for one will not feel the need to pay my money and register for a worthless title.
Craig Thomas, I.Eng

More comments ...

 


Comments disclaimer

Disclaimer: ETB will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all emails will be published. ETB reserves the right to summarise comments that are published. No comments are published anonymously, but you can indicate if you do not want your email address to be made public by ticking in the appropriate box. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of ETB.

 

 

 

"SET skills don’t simply respond to market needs; they actually create them, they stimulate them”

Alan Clark
Chief Executive, ETB

 
Privacy Policy