25 October 2002

 



ETB outlines plans to introduce Chartered Technologist qualification

 



We will feed all of your comments through to our working group and will respond accordingly from this website.

"The introduction of the Chartered Technologist aims to bring these engineers into the fold."...... Here we go again let's water it down before we start, are they Technologists or Engineers?

"In addition to being an attractive, contemporary title, complementary to the Chartered Engineer"...What's complimentary about it, it just reduces focus on Chartered Engineers who so far as I can see are paying for all of this.

“We see the Chartered Technologist as a multi-disciplinary professional who would have significant knowledge and experience of SET, underpinned by an academic framework. Under the heading of Technologist, we could licence companies to provide the chartered registration to their own employees."....... This is totally ludicrous, if you want talk ethica and standards as we have seen in the accounting sector, then don't involve industry at all.

"That would be a dramatic benefit to the companies, the employees, and to the profession."......... What profession ?

“It will become part of how people progress through their own company, and it allows the companies to use the chartering process as recognition of what their employees have achieved. It is very much a status underpinned by achievement.”........ No wrong, staus underpinned by good social climbing.

"The Hawley Report identified that only 600,000 of the 2m engineers in the UK are affiliated with a professional institution. ETB claims that their influence in government, industry and academia could grow if they became more coherent and cohesive, and this is what it will set out to do"......By watering it all down?

“The introduction of the Chartered Technologist has been described as probably the biggest change to the structure of the profession in the last hundred years,” said Clark. “Bioengineers, nanotechnologists, people in the NHS such as radiologists – all of these people should be part of our community. The Chartered Technologist qualification will bring them on the inside, bring them into the community, therefore benefiting the entire profession.”.......So good are they then that they should be able to apply in a normal way to a totally independent organisiation using the long standings rules and regulations for membership ?

"However, according to Trevor Evans, chief executive officer of the Institution of Chemical Engineers, ETB's proposals raise more questions than they answer."....I couldn't agree more with all his comments, are you just trying to wreck the engineering profession?
Malcolm Warren

In the recent BBC 'Top 100 Britons', I counted 17 engineers/scientists, no lawyers, no solicitors, no accountants, one business person etc. So why is it when I respond to the question "what do you do?" with "I'm a Chartered Engineer", do I get one of the following responses: "What's that then?" "Oh, Uhm, O.K." "Oh, does that mean you fix cars?".

New titles may be a good thing but more importantly the title 'Engineer' needs to be protected. No one can just call themselves a solicitor or a doctor and set up in practice, but there are no such regulations in engineering. The 1.4m unregistered engineers is testament to that.
It all boils down to the same thing which has been said for the last 20+ years that 'professional engineers' have no status in the UK. This remains to be addressed seriously. C.Tech, C.Sci may help this but in my opinion may cause more confusion. Registration, confusion, status, C.Eng/I.Eng should be tackled first.
Jeremy Hall

Here we go again! No wonder the public is confused. Allowing companies to award "chartered status" in a perverse form of "self regulation" will remove all credibility from chartership. However, there may be a need for a Chartered Technologist - BIAT is a typical architectural technology model, but the requirements should be as rigorous as all other varieties.
Brian Cook

It occurs to me that a CTech is aimed at people who have a multidisciplinary background, whereas I expect a CEng and the propspective CSci to be aimed at people who have a particular and long-term specialisation, such as one of the various engineering or scientific disciplines only.
Jo Thomas

Why is the International Register Of Professional Engineers not open to I.Eng?

1. Does this mean that an I.Eng is not Professional Engineer?

2. Is an I.Eng really a Engineering Technologist and not a Professional Engineer?

3. Why are I.Eng people always missing out?

4. Why can't we get Euring people with 3 year degrees?

5. Who recognises us at all?

Get some recognition for I.Eng people before bringing in new titles I think the these questions need to be addressed, or are they too hard?
B Roberts


There is no need to introduce another title to, and hence complicate, the existing title system. When J. Bloggs sees C.Tech after someone else's name they will treat it with the same contempt as B.Tech at the moment for not being the "Real McCoy". Changing the name of the profession from Engineering to Technologist also looks like an admission of defeat in the public perception of the name.
K McHattie

I was disheartened to read of the plans to introduce the Chartered Technologist title. I am an IEng, now working in Canada where the title "Technologist" is currently used. Upon emigrating to this country I applied for registration as a Professional Engineer and subsequently as a Technologist (the Incorporated Engineer title does not exist here). I was only 5 credits short of the academic requirement for the Professional Engineer registration, but pretty much received Technologist registration by return mail! The Washington Accord does not address this discrepancy. So by adding a Chartered Technologist title would, in my opinion, lower the status of UK educated professionals in the eyes of the Americas.

Also, for clarification... what exactly is the difference between a Chartered "Engineer", and by nature of incorporation through equivalent experience and qualifications, an Incorporated "Engineer"? Perhaps it is time to sort this out first before adding another title to the confusion?
Scott Barbour

Back ...

 


Comments disclaimer

Disclaimer: ETB will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all emails will be published. ETB reserves the right to summarise comments that are published. No comments are published anonymously, but you can indicate if you do not want your email address to be made public by ticking in the appropriate box. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of ETB.

 

 

 

"SET skills don’t simply respond to market needs; they actually create them, they stimulate them”

Alan Clark
Chief Executive, ETB

 
Privacy Policy