18 November 2002

 



Are employers given too powerful a voice in determining industry's training needs?


At a round table discussion hosted by City and Guilds, a group of education experts discussed the nature of training and education. Their conclusions? It’s a long road ahead. Full participant details are given at the bottom of this article.

Participants began by considering such fundamental questions as “who is training for?” and “how can you get a better understanding of the training needs of small businesses and get them engaged?” Attempts at finding an answer to the first question quickly led to considerations of public funding and the need to recognise the importance of “disentangling training from qualifications” (Judith Norrington).

David Bailey thought that government funding should broadly focus on those aspects of training that catered for an individual’s needs, leaving employers to pay for whatever directly benefited their company. He suggested that funding could be used to compensate employers for their absence from work while attending training courses, though he recognised that this approach seemed currently to be anathema to the government.

Dr Sa’ad Medhat pointed out that SMEs allegedly form 80% of the UK economy but that most have a myopic view of training. Though they should be focusing on productivity they tend to concentrate on survival. He spoke of a recent meeting with one Chief Executive who said she would not provide any training opportunities for staff unless they were “beneficial to the pipeline” (ie had an impact on sales). Certainly the approach of most dominant fast food outlets is that it is systems that matter not individual development, so training is focused on providing a slick and consistent service. Although turnover runs at some 60% this is acceptable in a low wage, low status industry. Geoff Marsh pointed out that SMEs embraced, in the building services sector, a large number of sole proprietors. These were typically people who had been through a traditional apprenticeship scheme but faced unemployment in the 1980s and set up their own businesses. They would previously have guided and taught the next generation, but now could not spare the time from their own enterprises and needed to be tempted back into the training programme by offering them appropriate remuneration.

Money is, not surprisingly, the root cause of another problem. Young people earning £60 a day are not likely to be tempted on to apprenticeships offering them £60 a week (even if this does represent more than is typically paid in Europe). They are well aware of what the current market can offer (though they may be surprised when conditions change). Chris Humphries pointed out that City & Guilds had witnessed a 46% increase in plumbing registrations in one year – stories in the press about shortages in this area had been quickly picked up by (mostly young) people keen to earn high wages.

Addressing the question posed in the topic for debate, participants agreed that, by and large, you had to look to employers to articulate training needs because no other group could do the job as effectively. However, there was little point in asking individual companies because they do not have the breadth of data - you had to look to representative bodies. The CBI spoke only for large companies and the Federation of Small Businesses was too small and appeared not to have an interest in training. For Dr Medhat, the Chambers of Commerce were too weak because it was not mandatory for employers to belong to them. Companies of whatever size would, however, only collaborate if (once again) there were clear benefits to the bottom line in doing so.

It was agreed that it was too early to judge the effectiveness of Sector Skills Councils, but predecessor bodies like Lead Bodies and Training & Enterprise Councils had not excelled at speaking for their sectors, so the omens were not encouraging. Geoff Marsh was worried that the representation of employers on SSCs was likely to be too narrowly defined – frequently there was no representation of manufacturers who more often than not provided training for operatives. The representative bodies for some sectors, for example EMTA and CITB, had by and large been successful, but in retail there had been disarray. The government had allowed small retailers to define standards that were fundamentally at odds with the interests of the larger companies and, as a result, the latter abandoned NVQs after three years in favour of their own training programmes. Though the British Retail Consortium has now been given responsibility for the sector, this was engineered by the government - not by the retail industry itself. This may not in itself be healthy. Participants were concerned that, like their predecessor bodies, SSCs might be wary of expressing views that their paymasters might not wish to hear. Given, too, that there was strong criticism from those at the Round Table of government for not listening to those who are looking for more commitment to vocational education and training, this is worrying. Chris Humphries suggested that there might be an improvement in the effectiveness of SSCs if they reported not to the DfES but to the DTI.

Governments in the past few decades and their civil servants (particularly in the DfES) were roundly condemned for listening only to Middle England, holding perversely to an academic perspective, and clearly misunderstanding both what employers and individuals needed. Participants gave as examples a recent conversation with a senior DfES civil servant who was lamenting that employers were critical of key skills “even though we gave them what they wanted”. The civil servant clearly did not understand that a survey conducted by QCA could not successfully have gathered employers’ views because of the circumstances in which it was conducted. Nor was it appropriate to require people who had “failed” academically at school to undertake an assessment that was “not about the application of skills but about some theoretical version of the application of skills” (Judith Norrington). Several participants immediately recognised another senior DfES civil servant (now retired) who had declared that employers were happy to release their staff for training one day a week and maintained that the chairman of McDonald’s had told him so - as if such businesses could live with a 20% reduction in productivity!

There is a cultural problem to be addressed which involves confronting snobbery and self-interest but which will not be helped by a government that exacerbates the academic bias in two significant policy areas – sixth form provision and the drive towards increasing HE participation rates.

It is not widely known that schools receive £2,500 for each 16-year-old who stays on in a sixth form and remains until the following November. Headteachers, anxious to attract such funding, often effectively deny objective guidance about options to these young people and their parents and then, ever mindful about the impact of league tables, discard those students who look as though they might not make the necessary grades. Colleges are then required to take on these "discards" who necessarily will have wasted some of the 2 years’ learning programme. Parents think that sixth form colleges are second best but the evidence is that they actually turn out better results. Chris Humphries went so far as to say that he thought abolishing sixth forms in schools would be the single best solution for stopping the artificial distortion of curriculum choice at 16.

Given the widespread disagreement with the government’s target of getting 50% of 18-30 year olds to have “some experience of HE” by 2010 it is surprising that it is still being pursued. Yet, according to one participant, the minister responsible is seriously considering raising the percentage target. Chris Humphries recounted hearing the Korean Deputy Permanent Secretary of the Department of Skills speak at a conference about the problems caused by having 75% of young people educated to degree level. About half of the cohort were either unemployed or fundamentally under-employed and there was little prospect of them contributing significantly to the economy because they did not have the right balance of skills. The dilemma for Korea was that successive governments had been preaching about the desirability of higher education for 25 years and they now had to convince parents that this was no longer true. At the same conference a Japanese official then said that they had a slightly smaller problem since only 65% of their young people were graduates, but basically the same problems were apparent.

It is perhaps ironic that in the UK we currently have about 50% of 16-year-olds who fail to reach the target of five GCSEs at A-C (essentially level 2). This not only raises the question of how you achieve 50% participation rates in HE for that cohort, it also leads one to question what is to be done for those who have "failed" the target. Stewart Segal felt that the bias towards an academic foundation had taken root and wondered how the cycle could be broken. It was suggested that the government should actually be focusing on a target of 50% achieving level 3 – a benchmark that would embrace both those achieving the entry requirements for HE (usually 3 A levels) as well as those who were successful in an equivalent vocational qualification (eg NVQ3). Culturally this would have far more impact in achieving ‘parity of esteem’ than the current policies.

Dr Sa’ad Medhat spoke of his determination to tackle the snobbery that still permeates the engineering profession. He felt the HE structures were too rigid, that programme lengths were inappropriate in some cases, and that too little regard was paid to the technician level – he acknowledged that chartered engineers were far too dominant. There was an unjustifiable emphasis on maintaining respect by insisting on graduate entry and/or on involvement in a limited number of massive projects. It is hard to avoid concluding that the consequent rationing of supply has much to do with the desire to maintain high earnings. At a recent discussion with RIBA it was clear, too, that architects are not prepared to adjust their membership criteria despite the shortages of technicians, nor is the medical profession prepared to allow nurses to progress to becoming doctors – a closed shop effectively operates so that doctors decide what tasks nurses may undertake. Tony Chandler felt that the NHS University would perhaps have a role in tackling some of these demarcations. (It was noted in passing how policy-makers had thought it necessary for the word ‘university’ to be applied to this organisation – and to UfI in its early days.)

For Tony Chandler, the most important aspect of training, particularly in the health and care sector where he works, is the achievement of higher quality through personal development, broadening experience and acquiring new skills so that you get an engaged, assertive workforce. He wondered whether we might learn from the German dual system which actively promotes the development of craft skills. This led to discussion about the attractiveness of some sort of statutory framework for training, which would help to engage employers more, provide recognition for skilled workers and boost consumer confidence. The major construction companies in the UK have agreed that, as from 1 January 2003, they will no longer employ people who do not have an appropriate qualification – they are effectively introducing a licence to practice which will trickle down and affect much of the sector. While it is true that this is the only sector where a levy still operates and that it has taken some 30 years to get to this point, it is nevertheless an encouraging development. Licence to practice arrangements have worked well for gas installation, though it is interesting that many of those already working as installers when the CORGI registration arrangements were introduced felt uncomfortable about putting themselves to the test and indeed paying the required fees. New entrants seem to show no such concerns.

Stewart Segal and David Bailey both pointed out that much of the discussion had focused on the manufacturing sector which covered only 25% of the employed workforce. They were both doubtful whether significant segments of the service sector would lend themselves to the sort of registration arrangements being discussed. Another market driven approach is gaining ground in the IT industry where standards are adopted which prospective employees feel obliged to attain. And they are prepared to pay for it out of their own pockets – some £6,000 for Microsoft Certified Engineer.

A major part of the service sector where a licence to practise system is being put in place is in health and care where all the aim is that there should be a fully qualified workforce. Apart from the benefits of focusing funding on those who traditionally have found it difficult to get access to training and development, the arrangements do of course provide assurance that care and treatment is being provided by fully qualified personnel. It should be viewed as a modest form of social engineering rather than as an example of centralised bureaucracy, and one of the benefits to employers is that it provides some protection against the cowboy competitors who have so often undercut because they were cutting corners and not using a qualified workforce. If consumers are assured of competent operatives they will probably be more prepared to pay the market rate for a service.

In summing up the Chairman, Robin Aitken wondered why it was that many of the issues that had been discussed and which were so clearly of importance to the public as a whole were not well aired. Where was there any informed debate about the need to reinvigorate the supply of technicians? How do you get advocacy on such matters and force the engagement of politicians? To those who have been engaged on this crusade for many years, there were no immediate solutions that sprang to mind. But the struggle continues…

Chair

Robin Aitken - Political correspondent, BBC Radio 4 ‘Today’ programme

Participants

David Bailey - Director of Training, A4E
Tony Chandler – Head of L & O/S Education, Unison
Chris Humphries - Director-General, City & Guilds
Geoff Marsh - Institute of Plumbing
Dr Sa’ad Medhat - Director of Education and Professional Development, ETB
Judith Norrington - Director of Curriculum & Quality, Association for Colleges
Stewart Segal - Training consultant

Rapporteur

Andrew Sich - City & Guilds

Observers

Bob Coates - City & Guilds
Martin Whittaker - TES
Cindy Withey - City & Guilds


 

 

"Licence to practice arrangements have worked well for gas installation."

 

 

"Another market driven approach is gaining ground in the IT industry where standards are adopted which prospective employees feel obliged to attain."

 

 

"If consumers are assured of competent operatives they will probably be more prepared to pay the market rate for a service."

 
Privacy Policy